It
can be argued that social networking sites such as Facebook make use
of malicious software that can violate privacy. Authoritarian regimes
can make
use of these
features to target human rights activist. But is our own government
using this same technology to track criminals? Since these
individuals are confirmed criminals is it ethical to violate there
fourth amendment rights? Crovitz describe such a case in which the
FBI uses a GPS to track Antoine Jone's. “The justices did their
best. The facts of U.S.
v. Antoine Jones
are that District of Columbia police, working with the FBI, suspected
a nightclub owner of being a drug dealer. They installed cameras near
Antoine Jones's nightclub, got his cellphone records, and attached a
GPS tracking device to his Jeep Grand Cherokee. In 2005, acting on
the information they had gathered, police executed a search warrant
and found a huge stash of cocaine, firearms and cash. The defendant's
lawyers objected to the GPS, saying that tracking car movements over
several weeks violated his expectation of privacy,” (Crovitz).
Crovitz argues that the fourth amendment should be “modernized”
to apply to recent technologies. Technology should be amended so that
it does not violate the fourth amendment. He gives an example,
“consider a case brought in the late 19th century. Actress Marian
Manola was playing a Broadway role requiring her to wear tights, a
racy outfit for the era. To protect her modesty, she got an
injunction when someone in the audience used the new technologies of
a camera and a flash light. By contrast, today actresses would be
insulted if they were not photographed”, (Crovitz). The actresses
has the right not to be photographed. Such is the case with once
popular musician Britney Spears who sued paparazzi for taking lewd
photographs. This is not true for the Facebook user either they are
unaware of the surveillance or they believe that they have a
social obligation to participate. Due to Facebook's terms of service
the user is unable to take legal action against Facebook or any of
its subsidiaries. More information pertaining to this article can be found here.
No comments:
Post a Comment